In a recent breakthrough, Hao Huang gave a 6 page paper proving the longstanding sensitivity conjecture. (Hat tip, Scott Aaronson and Gil Kalai. See this stackexchange post and this paper of Avishai for some links to the literature on this.)
The proof is beautiful and simple. I will write a few words here, but it is probably easier for you to just read the paper. The sensitivity conjecture was known to follow from the following statement: let be the Boolean Cube which is the degree
graph on
vertices identified with
such that for every
,
if their Hamming distance is one. Then, the maximum degree of every subgraph
of
of size
is at least
.
Hao proves the above statement by showing that there is a signing of the adjacency matrix of
that turns it into a matrix with
eigenvalues equaling
and
eigenvalues equaling
. That is, he shows (using a simple but clever inductive argument, see the 5 line proof of his Lemma 2.2) that there is an
matrix
with entries in
whose nonzero entries correspond to the edges of the Boolean cube, and such that all the
eigenvalues of
are
and they sum up to zero. (Note that this makes sense since
should have the same Frobenius norm as the adjacency matrix of
. The Frobenius norm squared is both the sum of squares of entries, which is
for
which is a degree
graph, and also equal to the sum of squares of the eigenvalues, which is
if all eigenvalues are
.)
Once you have such a signing, the result follows from Cauchy’s Interlace Theorem that says that for every matrix
and any
matrix
that is a principle sub-matrix of
,
where are the eigenvalues of
and
is the maximum eigenvalue of
. A corollary of this (which is the only fact we need) is that if
has its top eigenvalue
with multiplicity
(i.e.,
), then every principle sub-matrix
of order larger than
will satisfy
. (In fact, we only need
.)
Indeed, suppose that is a subgraph of the Boolean cube of size
. Then the principle submatrix
of
corresponding to the vertices of
satisfies
(since
and the first
eigenvalues of
are
).
But it’s easy to show that for every matrix
the maximum eigenvalue of
is upper bounded by the maximum
norm of its rows, which in our case is the maximum degree of the graph
.
Great result…great post
That there is a short proof of a long conjectured result is cool. It gives one hope that perhaps other results are possible.
Dick
Thanks Dick!